From the Chair · Planning Policy · July 2025

The NPPF December 2024: Five Concerns — and What a Better Response Would Look Like

Henry Higgins — Former Planning Committee Chair · 15 years on committee, 7 as Chair · July 2025

Homes matter. But the communities those homes go into matter more. You cannot build a housing target without building a place. The NPPF has forgotten that distinction.

I have sat in the chair of a planning committee for seven years. I have determined thousands of applications, managed hundreds of public hearings, and steered politically sensitive decisions through committees where the pressure — from developers, from residents, from officers, from members — was intense and often contradictory. I know what a functioning planning system looks like from the inside. And I know what it looks like when policy loses sight of the people it is supposed to serve. The December 2024 NPPF is driven by a genuine imperative. The housing crisis is real. The need for more homes is undeniable. On that there is no serious disagreement. But the response has created five problems that a more balanced approach to planning reform would have avoided.

What the Government got right

Brownfield first is the right instinct

The strengthening of the brownfield presumption in paragraph 124 is the right policy direction. Every derelict site, every vacant commercial building, every contaminated former industrial plot represents both a blight on the community and a housing opportunity. Brownfield first is not just environmentally correct — it is what residents consistently tell planning committees they want. The NPPF states the ambition. The delivery mechanisms remain underpowered.

The Golden Rules are a genuine concession to community

The requirement for 50% affordable housing, community infrastructure, and public green space on Grey Belt sites is a meaningful condition. From my time chairing planning committees I can say that the infrastructure question is what residents ask about most consistently. Not whether development happens, but whether the schools, the GPs, the roads, and the parks can cope. The Golden Rules, if enforced rigorously, begin to answer that question.

Five concerns

Concern 1 — Mandatory targets without mandatory infrastructure

The Government has made housing targets mandatory. It has not made infrastructure delivery mandatory at the same pace. You can legislate a target. You cannot legislate a GP surgery into existence. In Hillingdon, where I have sat on planning committees for 15 years, the most consistent failure is not in the number of homes granted permission. It is in the infrastructure that follows. Permissions are granted. Infrastructure commitments are made. And then they are not delivered at the pace residents were promised. A mandatory housing target without a mandatory infrastructure delivery plan is a promise that cannot be kept.

Concern 2 — Grey Belt will be used to justify exactly what it was designed to prevent

The Grey Belt definition is drawn tightly in the NPPF but will be stretched aggressively in practice. The exclusion of two of the five Green Belt purposes from the Grey Belt assessment means that developers can argue land is Grey Belt even where it clearly performs an important open space and countryside function. In the Heathrow corridor and across Hillingdon's Green Belt boundaries I expect to see a wave of Grey Belt applications over the next three years. Some will be appropriate. Many will not. The test will be whether planning committees have the policy framework and the political confidence to refuse the inappropriate ones.

Concern 3 — Neighbourhood plans have been quietly weakened

The requirement for Neighbourhood Plans to include specific site allocations as well as policies to get paragraph 14 protection is presented as a technical tidying-up. It is not. It materially weakens the position of communities that have invested significant volunteer time and resource in producing neighbourhood plans. This change effectively tells communities: your policies are not enough. You must tell us where the houses go, or we will not protect your plan from the tilted balance. For small parish councils with limited technical resource, this is an unreasonable burden.

Concern 4 — The Standard Method ignores local reality

Sevenoaks District Council, where 93% of the land is Green Belt, receives a housing target calculated on the same formula as Newham. The formula does not know that 93% of Sevenoaks is undevelopable. The disconnect between the number and the realistic delivery capacity of the most constrained authorities is not a rounding error. It is a fundamental design flaw that will generate years of appeals, legal challenges, and community conflict.

Concern 5 — Residents have less say, not more

The weakening of neighbourhood plan protection, the mandatory targets that override local preference, and the threat of intervention for councils that do not deliver enough permissions — all of these move power away from communities and towards central government and developers. Planning is a democratic process. It should be. When a community objects to a scheme and sets out coherent, policy-based reasons for that objection, those reasons should carry real weight. The December 2024 NPPF narrows the circumstances in which they can.

What a better response would look like

Residents are not obstacles to development. They are the people development is supposed to serve. A planning system that treats them as blockers has lost sight of its purpose.

The planning system needs to deliver more homes. That case is undeniable. But a more effective approach would prioritise brownfield sites with the tools to actually deliver them. It would make infrastructure delivery concurrent with housing delivery, not consequential to it. It would protect neighbourhood plan rights so communities retain genuine agency over their area. And it would ensure that Green Belt and Grey Belt release is genuinely exceptional, not a routine mechanism for meeting targets that the brownfield pipeline cannot absorb.

Policy Dashboard

See what the evidence base looks like for your area

The Policy Dashboard covers every authority in London and the Home Counties — updated as the evidence changes, not just when the plan does.

Explore the Dashboard Free

Work with Henry

Want to discuss your site or application?

Initial conversations are without charge. Most people leave with a clearer view of their position than they had going in.

Discuss Your Site

Work With Henry

The same insight, applied to your application

The perspective behind this analysis is the same perspective Henry brings to every client engagement. If you have a planning application, appeal, or expert witness instruction, get in touch.